The social evolution of human cooperation via group competition and conflict


Brendan O'Connor
Honors Thesis, Symbolic Systems
Readers: Noah Mark and James Fearon
March 2006

Abstract

Why do humans cooperate within large non-kin societies? A simple answer is that the ancestors of humans genetically evolved cooperative tendencies through millions of years of living in small groups where small-scale cooperation would be advantageous for survival. However, of the 50,000 year history of modern humans, only the last 10,000 have seen explosive growth in the size of human societies, from societies of several dozen members to societies of millions. I seek to explain the evolution of large-scale human cooperation as this increase in social order. I examine two previously underemphasized mechanisms to support cooperation: (1) institutional variance, and (2) war between societies. These two phenomena have been prevalent through the last 10,000 years of human history, and are unique to humans. In contrast to earlier work predominantly concerned with reciprocation and kin selection to support the evolution of cooperation, I develop evolutionary and rational choice models in which between-group competition and conflict help support within-group cooperation.

PDF